ADR Research on Parliamentarians

As the presidential of India is elected by a system of proportional representation, we wanted to see how it proportionally represents voters of our country. We have looked at the the affidavits submitted to the Election Commission of India of 772 out of 776 MPs and 4063 out of 4120 MLAs (a total of 4835 out of 4896) in all the states of India which forms the Electoral College and who will be voting on the Presidential Elections to elect the new President of India.

Documents attached:

1. Report on analysis of MPs and MLAs voting for Presidential Elections 2012 - Both in Hindi and English

2. Letter to Presidential Candidates to voluntary disclose criminal, financial, educational and other background details as per Supreme Court's guidelines.

3.Demands of NEW and ADR for Electoral and Political reforms

Here are the highlights of the reports:

 The following analysis shows that there is an urgent need for Electoral Reforms. NEW and ADR demands that the Political Parties take up the long pending Electoral immediately.

Highlights (Report on MPs and MLAs voting in Presidential Elections 2012):

• • National Election Watch (NEW) has analyzed the affidavits submitted to the Election Commission of India of 772 out of 776 MPs and 4063 out of 4120 MLAs (a total of 4835 out of 4896) in all the states of India which forms the Electoral College and who will be voting on the Presidential Elections to elect the new President of India.
  • As per the ECI, a total of 1098882 votes can be cast in the Presidential Elections.
  • Based on the number of votes these 4835 MPs/MLAs can cast, NEW & ADR has analysed 1089287 votes out the total 109882 votes.

  Votes of MPs/MLAs who have declared criminal cases

  • Out of the 4835 MPs/MLAs analyzed, 1448 members or 31 % have declared criminal cases against them in a self sworn affidavit filed with the ECI before their most recent elections.
  • Out of these 1448 voters who have declared criminal cases, 641 MPs/MLAs have declared serious criminal cases like rape, murder, attempt to murder, kidnapping, robbery, extortion etc.
  • There are 6 MPs/MLAs who have declared rape charges in their self sworn affidavits submitted to the ECI at the time of filing their nomination. There are 141 MPs/MLAs who have declared murder charges, 352 have declared attempt to murder charges, 145 have declared theft charges, 90 have declared kidnapping charges and 75 have declared dacoity charges.
  • Tainted Votes: Based on the number of votes that these tainted MPs/MLAs are entitled to cast, a total of (31%) or 335089 votes out of 1089287 analyzed are of MPs/MLAs who have declared criminal cases against themselves on self sworn affidavits submitted to the ECI at the time of filing their nomination papers for elections.
  • Among state assemblies, based on the number of tainted MLAs, the maximum number of tainted votes are from Uttar Pradesh which has 39312 out of 83824 votes analyzed (189 out of 403 MLAs) who have declared criminal cases at the time of submission of their self sworn affidavits to the ECI, followed by Maharashtra with 25550 out of 50225 votes analyzed (146 out of 287 MLAs) and Bihar with 24047 out of 41693 votes analyzed (139 out of 241 MLAs) who have declared criminal cases.
  • In terms of percentage of tainted votes, among state assemblies, Jharkhand has the highest % of tainted votes with 74% or 10560 out of 14256 votes (60 out 81 MLAs analyzed) followed by Bihar with 58% or 24047 out of 41693 votes (139 out of 241 MLAs analyzed) and Maharashtra with 51% or 25550 out of 50225 votes (146 out of 287 analyzed).

  Votes of MPs/MLAs based on financial details

  • A total of 2322 out of 4835 MPs/MLAs analyzed i.e. 48% are crorepatis as per their self sworn affidavits submitted to the ECI at the time of nomination for contesting elections.
  • Crorepati Votes: Based on the number of votes these crorepatis MPs/MLAs are entitled to cast, a total of 54% or 585918 out of 1089287 votes analyzed are of MPs/MLAs who are crorepatis.
  • Amongst state assemblies, Uttar Pradesh has the maximum number of crorepati votes with 56368 out of 83824 votes analyzed followed by Maharashtra with 34650 out of 50225 votes analyzed and Andhra Pradesh with 25308 out of 42772 votes analyzed.
  • In terms of Percentage, among state assemblies, Goa has the highest percentage of crorepatis voters with 92% or  (37 out of 40 MLAs analyzed) followed by  Punjab with 86% (101 out of 117 MLAs analyzed) and Haryana with 72% (65 out of 90 MLAs analyzed) crorepatis voters.

  Women Representation

• As per the data from ECI, out of the total 4896 MPs/MLAs who are entitled to vote in the upcoming Presidential Elections, only 418 or 9% are women.

• Based on the number of votes the MPs/MLAs are entitled to vote, the total number of women votes is 10% or 113145 out of 1098882 votes.

• Among MPs, Lok Sabha has 11% or 41772 votes out of 384444 from 59 women MPs and Rajya Sabha has 10% or 16284 out of 164964 from 23 women MPs.

• Among State assemblies, West Bengal has the maximum amount of women votes with 12231 votes out of 44394 (34 out of 294 MLAs), followed by Uttar Pradesh with 6656 votes out of 83824(32 out of 403 MLAs) and Bihar with 5882 votes out of 42039 (34 out of 243 MLAs).

• In terms of percentage, among state assemblies, the highest percentage of Women votes is from Bihar with 14% (34 out of 243 MLAs) followed by Rajasthan with 14% (28 out of 200 MLAs) women votes and West Bengal with 12% (34 out of 294 MLAs).

Thanks & Regards,

National Election Watch/Association for Democratic Reforms:

1. Journalist Data Helpline adr@adrindia.org (M: +91 8010394248)

2. Mr. Anil Bairwal, E: anil@adrindia.org, M: +91 8010394248, +91 9999310100, T: 011 40817601

3. Prof. Jagdeep Chhokar, E: jchhokar@gmail.com, M: +919999620944

4. Prof. Trilochan Sastry, E: trilochans@IIMB.ERNET.IN, M: +919448353285

S.No.	Contact's Position	Name	Email
	National Coordinator	Mr. Anil Bairwal	anil@adrindia.org
	Andhra Pradesh Election Watch	Mr. Ajay Gandhi	ajay@wingsinfo.net
	Andhra Pradesh Election Watch	Ms.Sowmya Kidambi	sowmyakrishkidambi@gmail.com
	Andhra Pradesh Election Watch	Mr. Rakesh Reddy Dubbudu	rakesh@bhumi.in
	Arunachal Pradesh Election Watch	Dr. Nani Bath	nanibath@rediffmail.com
	Assam Election Watch	Mr. Tasaduk Ariful Hussain	arif@nestinfo.org
	Bihar Election Watch	Mr. Rajiv Kumar	rajivkumar_patna@rediffmail.com
	Bihar Election Watch	Mr. Anjesh Kumar	anjesh.kumar@gmail.com
	Chhattisgarh Election Watch	Mr.Gautam Bandyopadhyay	gautamraipur@gmail.com
	Chhattisgarh Election Watch	Mr. Uma Prakash Ojha	ojhaup@gmail.com
	Goa Election Watch	Mr. Bhaskar Asssoldekar	vibhanatural@hotmail.com
	Gujarat Election Watch	Prof. Jagdeep Chhokar	jchhokar@gmail.com
	Gujarat Election Watch	Mr.Anand Padh	apadh.core@gmail.com
	Gujarat Election Watch	Mr. Manoj Thaker	apadh.core@gmail.com
	Haryana Election Watch	Mr. Jaskirat Singh	jaskirats@gmail.com
	Himachal Pradesh Election Watch	Mr. J.R Ramoul	yumdhahimachal@yahoo.com
	Himachal Pradesh Election Watch	Mr. P. R Ramesh	lkmtheog@yahoo.co.in
	Jammu & Kashmir Election Watch	Dr Muzaffar Bhatt	budgam_social@rediffmail.com
	Jharkhand Election Watch	Mr. Sudhir Pal	manthan_ranchi@hotmail.com
	Karnataka Election Watch	Mr. Trilochan Sastry	trilochans@iimb.ernet.in
	Karnataka Election Watch	Mr. Sridhar Pabbisetty	psridharp@gmail.com
	Karnataka Election Watch	Ms. Sindhu Naik	sindhunaik@gmail.com
	Kerala Election Watch	Mr T. Ravindran	ravindran@transmaticsystems.com
	Kerala Election Watch	Prof. Sudhir Kumar	sudhir.dcsmat@gmail.com
	Madhya Pradesh Election Watch	Mr. Rakesh Ranjan	rakeshranjan_rti@yahoo.co.in
	Maharashtra Election Watch	Mr. Ajit Ranade	ajit.ranade@gmail.com
	Maharashtra Election Watch	Mr. Nitin Valame	nitin.valame@gmail.com
	Manipur Election Watch	Mr. Tasaduk Ariful Hussain	arif@nestinfo.org
	Meghalaya Election Watch	Ms. Mayfereen Ryntathiang	mayfereenlyngdoh@gmail.com
	Mizoram Election Watch	Mr. Vanlalruata	mizoelectionwatch@gmail.com, ruataprism@yahoo.in
	Nagaland Election Watch	Ms. HekaniJakhalu	hekanijakhalu@yahoo.com
	Orissa Election Watch	Mr. Ranjan Kumar Mohanty	pecuc@hotmail.com
	Punjab Election Watch	Mr.Jaskirat Singh	jaskirats@gmail.com
	Pondicherry Election Watch	Mr. Victor	vrhope@gmail.com
	Rajasthan Election Watch	Mr. Nikhil Dey	nikhildey@gmail.com
	Rajasthan Election Watch	Mr. Kamal Tank	kamalrti@gmail.com
	Tamil Nadu Election Watch	Dr. Sudarsan Padmanabhan	sudarsanp@iitm.ac.in
	Tripura Election Watch	Mr. Biswendu Bhattacharjee	biswendu.tripura@gmail.com
	Uttar Pradesh Election Watch	Mr.I.C. Dwivedi	icdwivedi@gmail.com
	Uttar Pradesh Election Watch	Dr Lenin	pvchr.india@gmail.com
	Uttar Pradesh Election Watch	Mr. Sanjay Rai	sanjaykrai@yahoo.com
	Uttar Pradesh Election Watch	Mr. Sanjay Singh	sanjaysingh033@gmail.com
	Uttar Pradesh Election Watch	Mr. Mahesh Anand	gss_sonebhadra59@rediffmail.com
	Uttarakhand Election Watch	Dr. Ravi Chopra	psiddoon@gmail.com
	Uttarakhand Election Watch	Mr. Sanjay Sondhi	sanjay.sondhi1@gmail.com
	Uttarakhand Election Watch	Mr. BP Maithani	maithani_56@yahoo.com
	West Bengal Election Watch	Biplab Halim	bipimse@cal.vsnl.net.in, bipimse@hotmail.com
	West Bengal Election Watch	Dr. Ujjaini Halim	ujjainihalim@hotmail.com